United Nations Association of Australia

Informing, inspiring and engaging Australian's regarding the work, goals and values of the United Nations

Menu
  • Our Work
    • International Program
    • National Programs
      • Sustainable Development Goals Program
      • Human Rights Program
      • Climate Change Program
      • Global movement of people
      • Pacific Program
      • Peace Program
        • UNAA Peace Program website
        • Close
      • Australian Peacekeeping Memorial Project
      • Close
    • Local Programs
      • Division Programs
      • Young Professional Programs
      • Close
    • Critical Issues
    • Close
  • Teams
    • UNAA Divisions
      • Victoria Division
      • South Australia Division
      • New South Wales Division
        • NSW President’s Welcome
        • NSW Executive Committee
        • NSW Life Members
        • NSW Events
        • NSW Annual Reports
        • NSW Newsletter
        • NSW Membership
        • NSW Get Involved
        • NSW Lifeworks Awards
        • NSW Photo Gallery
        • NSW Media
        • NSW Sponsors
        • NSW Contact Us
        • Close
      • Queensland Division
        • QLD President’s Welcome
        • QLD Executive Committee
        • QLD Newsletter
        • QLD Events
        • QLD Join Us
          • QLD Membership
          • QLD Donations
          • QLD Volunteering
          • QLD Bequests
          • Close
        • QLD Community Awards
        • QLD Annual Reports
        • QLD Links
        • QLD Partners
        • Close
      • Australian Capital Territory Division
        • ACT President’s Welcome
        • ACT Events
        • ACT Membership
        • ACT Executive Committee
        • ACT Annual Reports
        • Close
      • Tasmania Division
        • TAS President’s Welcome
        • TAS Executive Committee
        • TAS Membership
        • Close
      • Northern Territory Division
        • NT President’s Welcome
        • NT Executive Committee
        • NT Annual Reports
        • NT Membership
        • Close
      • Western Australia Division
        • WA Contact Us
        • WA President’s Welcome
        • WA Membership
        • WA Newsletter
        • WA Programs for Schools
        • WA Committees
        • WA Resources
        • WA Yolande Frank Award Winners
        • WA Vacant Voluntary Positions
        • Close
      • Close
    • UNAA Young Professionals Network
      • UNAA QLD Young Professionals
      • UNAA ACT Young Professionals
      • UNAA WA Young Professionals
      • UNAA NSW Young Professionals
      • UNAA TAS Young Professionals
        • UNYP TAS Committee
        • Close
      • Close
    • UN Youth Australia
      • UN Youth Website
      • Close
    • Academic Network
    • UN Parliamentary Group
    • Close
  • Upcoming Events
  • About Us
    • About the UNAA
    • Our People
    • Our Patrons
    • WFUNA
    • Contact Us
    • Close
  • Get Involved
    • Donate
    • Membership
    • Volunteer
    • Intern
    • Awards Programs
    • Young Professionals Partnership Proposal
    • Sponsorship
    • Shop
    • Close
  • News
    • Media and Press Releases
    • Latest UNity News
    • Close
  • Learn
    • Factsheets
    • Useful Links
    • About the UN
      • Short history of the UN
      • UN: Working Around the World
      • UN Observance Days
      • UN International Observance Years
      • Close
    • Photo Gallery
    • Australia and the UN
      • Australia’s role in the UN
      • Australia and UN Security Council
      • The UN in Australia
      • Close
    • Working with the UN
    • UNAA Podcasts
    • UNAA Videos
    • School Teaching Resources
    • UNAA Submissions and Reports
    • Close
  • Donate
Home / News / High Court Rules Nauru Detention Centre is Constitutional

February 5, 2016

High Court Rules Nauru Detention Centre is Constitutional

05-06-2015Nauru_DetentionOn Wednesday 3rd February, the Australian High Court heard a case brought forward by the Human Rights Law Centre, concerning a plaintiff from Bangladesh who stood to be deported back to Nauru. The case challenged the lawfulness of the detention centre in a third party State along with the Government’s funding of it. Unfortunately, the case was dismissed with the final decision that the detention centre on Nauru was entirely in line with Australian constitution.

Whilst the emerging reports of multiple abuses of basic human rights continue to cause concern, courts are being forced to consider whether a person faces serious risk in returning to Nauru. One such case includes that of a five year old boy who was allegedly raped in Nauru by a person who is still residing there. Unfortunate though this is, the morality of the issue was not in question for the High Court, which found in favour of the Government with a majority 6-1 vote. Daniel Webb from the Human Rights Law Centre, who brought the case forward, spoke on ABC radio before the hearing, saying that it was not only legality, but morality that had to be considered. In this sense, the argument strayed from the primary agenda in that morality does not change the nature of the constitution and the High Court found that the Australian Government is well within its rights to detain migrants at Nauru and, furthermore, that funding for the centres is entirely valid.

The validity of funding was called into question due to a slight amendment made to the Constitution last year. This change was drawn with the expectation of the challenge from the Human Rights Law Centre. Justice Michelle Gordon, who offered the only dissenting opinion, felt this recent June addition to the constitution was rushed and created an invalid loophole.

By funding the deportation and all other living costs, including $3000 for a Protection Visa, the Australian government then hands over all responsibility to Nauru. Now, whilst punitive detention of an asylum seeker is illegal under international law, the Australian government has made it clear that they have not remanded any person into custody onto Nauru, despite the fact that the Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) between Australia and Nauru requires forcible detention of the applicant in the Regional Processing Centre, which is on Naura and secured by perimeter fencing and private contractors Transfield and Wilson Security.

Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull maintains his strict stance on people smugglers, citing the importance of border security as the primary goal behind the regime of deportation for asylum seekers. The Australian Government may be using the detention centres as exemplary models to deter potential people smugglers and illegal immigrants, however the conditions on Nauru for those who have already arrived may continue to be sacrificed for the broader message that our government is sending.

Human Rights experts from the United Nations urged Australia to consider the interests of children facing deportation to Nauru. Immigration Minister Peter Dutton says that decisions on deportation will be considered individually, based on medical conditions. while over ten churches and cathedrals have offered the ancient practice of sanctuary to any asylum seekers, reflecting the overall spirit of compassion that Australia has adopted for those seeking a better life.

Filed Under: News

Sign up for our Newsletter

Latest Tweets

UN STUDY TOURS - NEY YORK & GENEVA The @UNAA_National & @unaavic is pleased to announce small group study tours to… https://t.co/juE2goVkvi
6 hours ago

Today we celebrate World Day of #SocialJustice 🥳 Reaffirming that full employment and decent work results in univer… https://t.co/oclw1nCzLh
6 hours ago

yesterday

Want to build connections and find out what its like to work for the United Nations? Register now for… https://t.co/W2jSrEw5g5
yesterday

© 2019 United Nations Association of Australia

Suite 206, Griffin Centre, 20 Genge Street
Canberra City, ACT 2601 Australia
Contact Us · admin@unaa.org.au · ABN 47 836 436 168

Privacy Policy

Designed by Atlassian · Hosted by verv creations